Is sustainability reporting Mandatory for all businesses?

Is sustainability reporting Mandatory for all businesses?

Are you looking for the right CSRD solution?
Use our guides and database with +100 CSRD solutions.
Learn more
Need help with CSRD? Here is an overview.
Do you have to comply with CSRD?
Download our Free CSRD Guide now.
Learn more

Effective CSR reporting can yield social, environmental, and financial benefits, but its success hinges on well-considered standards and credible enforcement. It should be noted that nearly 96% of the world’s largest 250 companies reported on their sustainability performance in 2020, indicating a growing trend towards CSR accountability.

Mandatory CSR Reporting: A Global Trend

Mandatory CSR reporting, while focused on the U.S., offers insights applicable globally. It could significantly benefit capital markets and influence a business's social and environmental impact, provided that the reporting rules are well-designed. However, the current voluntary nature of CSR reporting leads to significant variations in reporting practices, making it difficult for stakeholders to trust and compare company performances. Mandatory standards could compel even reluctant firms to disclose their CSR activities, leading to improved disclosures in terms of volume and quality.

The potential effects of mandatory CSR reporting are complex, with both positive and negative outcomes. Positive impacts include ensuring genuine social and environmental benefits and enabling stakeholders to exert meaningful pressure on firms to improve their practices. However, there are risks too, such as reduced competitiveness or clashes between stakeholder interests. Effective CSR reporting standards need to balance specificity and breadth and require significant investment in enforcement infrastructure and expertise. Despite the costs, developing and enforcing a reliable CSR reporting framework is crucial, especially as investors and CEOs increasingly recognize the importance of sustainable investments and broader stakeholder interests.

The Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD)

There is an increasing importance of sustainability reporting for both public and private sector companies, driven by new laws and regulations like the Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD). The CSRD expands the requirement for sustainability reporting to include all large legal entities with limited liability, and this applies indirectly to public companies regardless of their size. The implementation of these regulations is staged: January 1, 2024, for companies already under the Directive on non-financial information disclosure; January 1, 2025, for large companies not currently under this directive; and January 1, 2026, for listed SMEs and certain financial institutions.

The CSRD mandates that once a public company is obligated to develop sustainability reporting, the EU taxonomy automatically applies. However, there's ambiguity surrounding whether certain public law institutions and state-owned enterprises are obligated under the CSRD. In Germany, most public companies must prepare financial statements and management reports like large corporations, which may lead to an obligation to prepare sustainability reports.

Municipal associations are advocating for amendments to municipal codes to possibly exempt some entities from CSRD reporting obligations. Despite these legal complexities, the article suggests that municipal companies and municipalities should adopt sustainability reporting for compliance reasons and due to their public role.

The Importance of Sustainability Reporting

Sustainability reporting covers a wide range of issues including environmental concerns, employee issues, social concerns, and is supplemented by the EU Taxonomy Regulation. Various standards and frameworks can support companies in this endeavor. While it is challenging, sustainability reporting offers opportunities for reputation enhancement and stronger community connections. It highlights both external "push" factors like legal requirements and internal "pull" factors like public consciousness towards sustainability as motivations for companies to report sustainably.

In conclusion, sustainability reporting is both a challenge and an opportunity for companies to demonstrate their commitment to sustainability and enhance public and stakeholder trust.

The Methodology of Preparing a Sustainability Report

It's primarily mandatory for publicly traded and large companies in the insurance banking sector as per EU Directive 2014/95/EU. These reports, prepared annually voluntarily, detail the economic, social, and environmental impacts of a company's activities. Steps for drafting a sustainability report following the Global Reporting Initiative (GRI) guidelines include stakeholder mapping, materiality analysis, and data collection. Additionally, there's a difference between sustainability, social, and environmental reports, and underscores the benefits of sustainability reporting for improving corporate reputation, accessing financing, and efficient risk management.

A step-by-step guide to selecting the right CSRD solution.

Screen around 100 CSRD solutions in minutes not weeks, and create an individualized list of solutions.

A laptop showing the CSRD solution finder guide.